Tuesday, November 23, 2010

YEP!! still typing....

The approach of totaly student driven learning that is I admit still a distant spectre on the horizon, the practical considerations and the effect on the professional and personal lives of tutors of such a system and its allied assessment methods are still to be broached. There will be a day when this is a viable approach, however this will probably not be in the foreseeable future. There is a movement towards a more student driven assessment methodology however, if this is an improvement or just the current in-vogue train of thought prevalent among those we must obey, is still to be proved. In my experience or to be exact my wife,s experience of " student self-assessment ", the main effect of this currently much enthused about piece of assessment new-age dogma was to bring approximately half the group to ask " if we are doing this why are we paying for a tutor??? ".The new ideas of these approaches to both teaching and assessment must be used with care and careful preparation by the user, the opportunity for improvement in both areas is clearly demonstrated in John Hattie,s Meta-Analysis and the improvement shown or detrimental effects of the various ideas is given as a quatifiable ratio. How individuals interpret and apply the various forms of educational, teaching, assessment and learning ideas will obviously change the outcomes of these methods.
There are other factors that will also have to be taken into account, as much as we are being encouraged to design around and employ these all encompassing  "new-wave" ( there,s a blast from the past ) this will fix it " vunder-metods", we have to remember that our abilities as assessors vary greatly, but far more importantly our students abilities as learners vary almost infinitely more than we can possibly imagine. Their learning is influenced by factors far to many to list in such a commentary home enviroment, peer pressure, indvidual ability, enthusiasm, interest, maturity and socio-economic background to mention just a few of these contributing forces. That among others are all affecting learning outcomes for the students and thus their ability to not only apply their learning in an assessment or to an assessment task, but to be able to cope with the assessment enviroment itself.
No matter how we dress it up or what terminology we use a test is a test in anybodies language! We must above all be honest with ourselves and more importantly with the students. Failure is an option!!! There I,ve said that most deep, dark and deplorable of phrases, " he who shall not be named", has been spoken of , as much as we must endeavour to provide a supportive learning enviroment, with a truthful and fair assessment criteria, using the best tools at our disposal. We must never comit that most heinous of educational offences," pandering to the fashion of the day". When all said and done it is our name on the Doctors degree, Nurses diploma, Coaches C.V. and Kindergarten teachers R.O.L. To be honest is sometimes disappointing, sometimes deeply discouraging and occasionaly downright brutal. It is however the truth, as distastful as that may be it is a fact of life! We cannot and must not design an assessment no matter how well meaning its intent, that is intended to produce an outcome rather than measure an effect. Some may feel that this is a rather jaundiced view of what we are trying to achieve, but it has been said to us that " we are just plucked from industry and stuck in front of a class and expected to teach".But for me that poses a question, can you take the veiw that purely theoretical knowledge is enough, or do we gain something more through practical employment of that knowledge??. That perhaps is why we are here , we have the knowledge in our own fields to make such a judgement call to assess if someone has learnt enough to be released upon the unsuspecting world. We are here to hone the skills to improve our abilities at doing that, making that judgment call.
Likewise with assessment the level of comprehension of a given subject or skill cannot be and must not become a dogmatic diatribe of "only this will do",or conversely the opposite side of the coin the " she,ll be right " methodology, this is surely what we are here to learn. How we apply what we know to ensure that those we teach are competent at what we expect them to have learnt and how to use that aquired knowledge correctly.
I think it does all come down to the fact that we (according to a bunch of other jokers) know our own subjects, what we are trying to do is make sure that those that follow us also know what they are doing!!! If we fail to carry out this task honestly then the only people to carry the blame for this failure is ourselves, of this I am sure. We have been given a number of tools and methods to measure not only our students success but also our own! I for one will be using and in fact have already employed some of these methods, the system I was educated in does make some ideas difficult to cope with, but that,s why we are here isn,t it????

No comments:

Post a Comment